MxMO – Spice

December 15th, 2008

Mixology Monday - Spice

The last Mixology Monday this year is hosted by Craig over at Tiki Drinks & Indigo Firmaments and has the rather seasonal theme of spice. When I think about spice and alcohol this time of year the first thing that springs to mind is mulled wine, however despite its frequent occurrence throughout my winters since I was old enough to have a small sip from my parents glass I’ve never been a huge fan of the stuff.

By contrast, Winter Pimm’s is a drink I hadn’t ever tried until about this time last year, but now wouldn’t like to experience a cold winter without. Based on the No. 3 cup, made with brandy rather than gin as with the No. 1 cup, Winter Pimm’s is a delicious mix of fruit, spice and brandy, and makes for a perfect winter warmer when combined with apple juice and some fresh apples and oranges.

I recently learned that Austin’s, a Pimm’s-imitating brand sold in budget supermarket Aldi here in the UK, is now making a Winter Drink in an attempt to compete with Pimm’s Winter Cup, so eager to find out if it was any good I quickly went out in search of a bottle. At half the price of Pimm’s Winter Cup I certainly hoped it was decent, but how does it stand up to the real thing?

Winter Pimm's No. 3 Cup and Austin's Winter Drink

Whereas Pimm’s Winter Cup is brandy-based, Austin’s Winter Drink gets it’s alcoholic kick from wine and grain spirits. On the nose the Austin’s doesn’t seem all that different to their Summer Drink with a slightly sweet fruitiness, though there is a little more bitter orange and a definite cinnamon presence at the end. The Pimm’s has a more aromatic bouquet, with plenty of cinnamon and other spices, and a milder orange background.

In the mouth the Austin’s is fairly weak, with a slightly watery consistency and an orange-led flavour with a little spice in the background. The Pimm’s has a richer taste, with a slightly sweeter aromatic body, a zesty, slightly bitter orange, and plenty of spices going on. It also has a longer spice finish compared with the short, sweet and fairly bland finish of the Austin’s. Unfortunately where the Austin’s Summer Drink represents a reasonable (though inferior) alternative to Pimm’s when you’re on a budget, Austin’s Winter Drink is merely inferior.

Clear that Pimm’s Winter was the way forward, I wanted to try and create a traditional cocktail that incorporates the delicious marrying of Pimm’s No. 3 and apples. Given the brandy base of Pimm’s Winter a Sidecar immediately sprang to mind, so using Pimm’s as the base I added applejack for some extra oomph and the apple flavours I wanted plus some lemon juice and Cointreau to brighten up the drink, and some Angostura bitters to round everything out.

Winter Sidecar cocktail

Winter Sidecar

View in: oz | ml | shots

The result is an aromatic mixture that isn’t nearly as heavy as you might expect. The Pimm’s and applejack work well together, and while the drink doesn’t reach the simple perfection of a classic Sidecar it is a nice variation for the winter.

Subcribe using RSS Share this page

Posted in Applejack, Aromatic Bitters, Curaçao & Triple Sec, Lemon, Mixology Monday, Pimm's, Recipes, Reviews

If you liked this, the barman recommends...

9 responses to “MxMO – Spice”

  1. Vidiot Vidiot says:

    Neat! I’ve been wanting to try the Winter Pimm’s for ages.

  2. Anita / Married …with Dinner Anita / Married ...with Dinner says:

    I can’t wait to get my hands on some winter pimm’s… mmm!

  3. Tristan Tristan says:

    I’ve got a cold and Pimm’s Winter is doing a good job of helping me through it. Neat and straight out of the bottle, just the way that grandpa would do it!

  4. Rick Rick says:

    I’ll have to echo everyone’s comments. I’d love to give their Winter formula a try. Jay, what other ones do they still make?

  5. Tiki Drinks & Indigo Firmaments » Blog Archive » Mixology Monday Wrap-up December 2008 - Spice says:

    [...] at Oh Gosh! is a charming fellow. I also made his acquaintance at Tales this year after following his wise and [...]

  6. Jay Jay says:

    Rick – They still make the gin-based No. 1 (obviously), vodka-based No. 6 (which is only available in limited quantities, and to be honest I’ve never bothered trying), and this Winter Pimm’s which is brandy-based No. 3 plus extra spices and orange. Sadly the interesting sounding ones based on whisky, rye and rum were discontinued in the 70s, and the current ones are weaker than they used to be.

    A higher strength Winter Pimms with more brandy character would be amazing – and would certainly do wonders for Tristan’s cold! ;-)

  7. Tristan Tristan says:

    The Vodka one is a bit poor to be honest. It is both lighter in colour and weaker tasting than the gin cup.

    Plymouth fruit cup beats them all, but I have a feeling it has been discontinued… :(

  8. Jay Jay says:

    Tristan – Totally agree the Plymouth Cup is indeed the best, and sadly it has indeed been discontinued. I managed to grab a few bottles earlier this year, it is still around if you look hard. Don’t know for how much longer though…

  9. Colonel Tiki’s Drinks » Blog Archive » Mixology Monday Wrap-up December 2008 - Spice says:

    [...] at Oh Gosh! is a charming fellow. I also made his acquaintance at Tales this year after following his wise and [...]

Leave a Comment

Warning: Illegal string offset 'solo_subscribe' in /nfs/c08/h03/mnt/126554/domains/ on line 305

Subscribe without commenting

Get free updates from A dash of Oh Gosh!

Or subscribe to Oh Gosh! using an RSS reader RSS Entries Feed

© 2007-2018 Oh Gosh! – All Rights Reserved

Photography by Jay Hepburn
Artwork by Craig Mrusek

Win an ice ball maker

Plus a bitters travel kit from The Bitter Truth, Miller's 10th Aniversary Gin, Martini Bitter, and a Mozart Dry bartender's set. For a chance to win...

Just subscribe to A dash of Oh Gosh!

Full details & rules